| Andy Basten | Green Bay Blue Ribbons | 2023 |
| Rick Baumgart | Sheboygan A's | 2023 |
| Bob Gillespie | Addison Braves | 2023 |
| Steve Elliott | West Allis Nationals | 2023 |
| Mark Cibrario | Kenosha Kings | 2023 |
| Mike Flanigan | Oshkosh Giants | 2022 |
| Dr. Jerry Staub | Rockton | 2022 |
| Gus Burwell | Madison Avenue Bar | 2022 |
| Taylor Schwarz | Sheboygan A's | 2022 |
| Nick Mitidiero | Lombard Orioles | 2022 |
| Ricky Angell | Lombard Orioles | 2020 |
| Steve Kostichka | Green Bay Blue Ribbons | 2020 |
| Jared Koutnik | Lombard Orioles | 2020 |
| Jon Olson | Kenosha Kings | 2020 |
| Jeff Schmitz | Janesville Aces | 2020 |
| Al Albert | Sheboygan A's | 2019 |
| Tom Bennett | Madison Avenue Bar | 2019 |
| Mike Brooks | Janesville Aces | 2019 |
| Mike Ruechel | Green Bay Blue Ribbons, Marshfield Chaparrals | 2019 |
| Steve Ryder | Addison Braves | 2019 |
| Randy Johnson | Kenosha Kings | 2018 |
| Billy Johnson | Kenosha Kings | 2018 |
| Brian Neveau | Oshkosh Giants | 2018 |
| Clay Schwartz | Sheboygan A's | 2018 |
| Paul Wilmet | Green Bay Blue Ribbons | 2018 |
| Matt Fredricks | Janesville Aces | 2017 |
| Steve Ploetz | Madison Avenue Bar | 2017 |
| Boyd Rohde | Horicon Hurricanes | 2017 |
| Matt Rohde | Horicon Hurricanes | 2017 |
| Bob Sauger | Sheboygan A's | 2017 |
| Steve Colaizzi | Addison Braves | 2016 |
| Jerry Frisque | Green Bay Blue Ribbons | 2016 |
| Dave Kober | Sheboygan A’s | 2016 |
| Greg O’Brien | Madison Avenue Bar | 2016 |
| Dan Zeratsky | Green Bay Blue Ribbons | 2016 |
| Jim Kating | Lombard Orioles | 2015 |
| Chris Kilen | Janesville Aces | 2015 |
| Carl Maglio | Madison Avenue Bar | 2015 |
| John Nelson | Green Bay Blue Ribbons | 2015 |
| Howie Norsetter | Madison Avenue Bar | 2015 |
| Tim Pulizzano | Kenosha Kings, Racine | 2015 |
| Jason Bartelt | Sheboygan A's | 2014 |
| Rich Graham | Addison Braves, Lombard Orioles | 2014 |
| Dave Halford | Madison Howard Johnson | 2014 |
| Josh Krowiorz | Manitowoc Bandits, Sheboygan A's | 2014 |
| Joe Shere | Janesville Aces | 2014 |
| RD Boschulte | Madison Avenue Bar | 2013 |
| Troy Evers | Green Bay Blue Ribbons | 2013 |
| Tom Gardner | Sheboygan A's | 2013 |
| Bill McQueen | Janesville Aces | 2013 |
| Mike Pierce | Addison Braves | 2013 |
| Steve Schulz | Green Bay Blue Ribbons | 2013 |
| Marty Bell | Madison Avenue Bar | 2012 |
| Tom Eckhardt | Sheboygan A's | 2012 |
| Tony Geharz | Menasha Macs, Oshkosh Giants | 2012 |
| Larry Kurkowski | Addison Braves | 2012 |
| Bryan Purchatzke | Oshkosh Giants | 2012 |
| Cory Schaefer | Green Bay Blue Ribbons, Oshkosh Giants | 2012 |
| Mark Zeratsky | Green Bay Blue Ribbons | 2012 |
| Michael Casper | Sheboygan A's | 2011 |
| Dave Christman | Green Bay Blue Ribbons, Oshkosh Giants, Racine | 2011 |
| Tom Imhoff | Janesville Aces | 2011 |
| Paul O'Callaghan | Lombard Orioles | 2011 |
| Tom Zoch | Green Bay Blue Ribbons, Marshfield Chaparrals, Oshkosh Giants | 2011 |
| Pat Campbell | Janesville Aces | 2010 |
| Dave Gehr | Sheboygan A's | 2010 |
| Mark Hinske | Green Bay Blue Ribbons, Menasha Macs | 2010 |
| Mark Rohde | Horicon Hurricanes | 2010 |
| Dick Zeratsky | Green Bay Blue Ribbons | 2010 |
| Troy Cota | Green Bay Blue Ribbons, Oshkosh Giants | 2009 |
| Dan Miller | Green Bay Blue Ribbons, Oshkosh Giants, Sheboygan A's | 2009 |
| Phil Plamann | Appleton Legends, Green Bay Blue Ribbons | 2009 |
| Tim Richardson | Lombard Orioles | 2009 |
| Chuck Zeichert | Sheboygan A's | 2009 |
| Rich Capparelli | Lombard Orioles | 2008 |
| Mark Miller | Green Bay Blue Ribbons | 2008 |
| Steve Rothenbach | Oshkosh Giants | 2008 |
| Juff Vukovich | Lombard Orioles | 2008 |
| Terry Young | Green Bay Blue Ribbons | 2008 |
| Jim Coulter | Janesville Aces | 2007 |
| Dan Davis | Beloit Blues, Green Bay Blue Ribbons, Janesville Aces | 2007 |
| Greg Howell | Green Bay Blue Ribbons | 2007 |
| Tom Klawitter | Janesville Aces | 2007 |
| Greg Lavarone | Lombard Orioles | 2007 |
| Gene Mand | Sheboygan A's | 2007 |
| Denny Moyer | Sheboygan A's | 2007 |
| Dennis Ruh | Green Bay Blue Ribbons | 2007 |
| Lee Wetenkamp | Sheboygan A's | 2007 |
| Randy Wilke | Sheboygan A's | 2007 |
Since the Wisconsin State League Hall of Fame was formed in 2007, 89 individuals have had the honor of being inducted into the prestigious Hall of Fame.