2011
Nolan Fadness - Eau Claire Cavaliers
2010
Mark Cibrario - Kenosha Kings
2009
Nate Roberts - Lombard Orioles
2008
Brad Demmin - Oshkosh Giants
2007
Mark Cibrario - Kenosha Kings
2006
Bryan Schwebke - Oshkosh Giants
2005
Joe Shere - Janesville Aces
2004
Luke Martin - Kenosha Kings
2003
Bob Diliberto - Lombard Orioles
2002
Steve Ryder - Addison Braves
2001
Randy Wilke - Sheboygan A's
2000
Jason Bartelt - Sheboygan A's
1999
Rob Bruce - Lombard Orioles
1998
Casey Kopitzke - Green Bay Blue Ribbons
1997
Randy Wilke - Sheboygan A's
1996
Jeff Allen - Lombard Orioles
1995
Jeff Allen - Lombard Orioles
1994
Cory Schaefer - Green Bay Blue Ribbons
1993
Dan Miller - Green Bay Blue Ribbons (co-Most Valuable Player)
1993
Tom Bardner - Sheboygan A's (co-Most Valuable Player)
1992
Jim Kating - Lombard Orioles
1991
Dan Miller - Green Bay Blue Ribbons (co-Most Valuable Player)
1991
Greg DePagter - Sheboygan A's (co-Most Valuable Player)
1990
Mike Brooks - Janesville Aces (co-Most Valuable Player)
1990
Tom Imhoff - Janesville Aces (co-Most Valuable Player)
1989
Lee Wetenkamp - Sheboygan A's
1988
Lee Wetenkamp - Sheboygan A's
1987
Chris Delarwelle - Oshkosh Giants (co-Most Valuable Player)
1987
Mike Liebenstein - Madison Avenue Bar (co-Most Valuable Player)
1986
Howie Norsetter - Madison Avenue Bar (co-Most Valuable Player)
1986
Greg Roscoe - Madison Avenue Bar (co-Most Valuable Player)
1985
Lee Wetenkamp - Sheboygan A's
1984
Jeff Schyvinck - Delavan
1983
Steve Sobojinski - Oshkosh Giants
1982
Joe Scime - Madison Avenue Bar
1981
Tony Wilbur - Green Bay Blue Ribbons (co-Most Valuable Player)
1981
Lee Wetenkamp - Sheboygan A's (co-Most Valuable Player)
1980
Dave Halford - Madison Howard Johnson
1979
Steve Schulz - Green Bay Blue Ribbons
1978
Tom Zoch - Oshkosh Giants
1977
Mark Hinske - Menasha Macs
1974
Greg Howell - Green Bay Blue Ribbons
1973
Greg Howell - Green Bay Blue Ribbons
1972
Jim Zaher - Beloit Blues
1971
Greg Gaffey - Beloit Blues
1970
Steve Wilmet - Green Bay Blue Ribbons